I Hate to Admit This But...Talking About Money in Church Makes Me Uncomfortable - Midtown

I Hate to Admit This But...Talking About Money in Church Makes Me Uncomfortable - Midtown

November 15, 2026 • Rev. Mindie Moore

I Hate To Admit This But : Week 3 


Talking About Money in Church Makes Me Uncomfortable 


1 Corinthians 16:1-4 


Today we are wrapping up our Stewardship series, where we take a few weeks every single year to focus on what it means to live generously and intentionally. And today we conclude this conversation with celebrating the year behind us and looking ahead to next year through our pledge intention moment. In your bulletin, there's a card that you can fill out to make your intention for how you plan to support the ministry of St. Luke's in 2027.  


Before we get to that moment, we're looking at one more "honest confession" about Stewardship. And it's one that's perfect for a day like today: (SLIDE) Talking about money in church makes me uncomfortable. Because, yes, today is a day when we talk about money! 


I think it's fair to say that money and the church have...a complicated relationship. A great example of how we've attempted to process this was highlighted in the Instagram account "Preachers 'n Sneakers." A man named Ben Kirby anonymously started this account in 2019, where he would post pictures of megachurch pastors and the outfits they wore to lead on Sunday mornings, and then he would highlight the different designer pieces they were wearing. (SLIDE) One preacher wore a pair of $1250 Nikes; another a $430 Gucci belt. Week after week, he posted these expensive outfits, with a seemingly endless supply of content.  


The account blew up—Kirby hit over 100,000 followers within the first month, and at its most popular had over 300,000 people following along, to see the next outfit he would post. There were, of course, some naysayers, but most of his followers were appalled at the excess and the way these preachers appeared to be using their money. THIS, the comments said, was a perfect example of why people didn't trust the church when it came to money. 


Even though this was a pretty specific way to showcase this conflict, I think it speaks to the broader feelings that can exist when it comes to this conversation. There are a lot of people who have doubts about how churches use the money they receive. Is it actually going to do good, or is it just going to pad someone's bank account? Should we really be giving to an institution like this, or directing our resources elsewhere? We might even just have some personal reservations—we might be people who were taught that you don't talk about money ANYWHERE, so why in the world are we trying to do that in a context like church? 


And maybe, on the surface, this particular Sunday feels like one where we DO just want to talk about finances and the bottom line of what people will give. But I wonder if we might reframe it just a bit, and look at this as less of a Sunday to talk about MONEY...and more of a day to talk about GIVING. 


That's what I think is at the heart of what Paul is writing about here in the Scripture we read today. Just to give us a little background, Paul is writing to the church at CORINTH and he's instructing them on how to give to the church in JERUSALEM. It's a chance for one church community to help another as a reflection of their growing faith.  


When Paul is writing this, the church in Jerusalem is in a tough place. They've grown at an incredible rate...but they've also faced some major challenges. They've experienced a famine, high rates of poverty, and persecution for what they believe. Paul has become very familiar with their struggle, and because of that, he's made commitments to them that they don't have to do this alone. He's going to find other communities to help support them, to show them that the whole family of God is with them in their time of need. 


This connection is incredibly important, maybe even more than we fully realize. Because this connection doesn't just span geography—it spans identity. The giving that the Corinthian church is going to be part of not only addresses practical needs that the Jerusalem church might have, but it also does something else—it helps create unity between Jews and Gentiles. It takes these two very different, and often opposing, cultures, and says: there's something bigger here that holds you all together. Despite whatever differences you might have, you're still part of the bigger family of God. 


That understanding, that we are part of God's big, expansive family, is a really powerful thing to consider as we give. One thing I've really been untangling as we've talked about stewardship this year is that while in some ways I was given a strong blueprint of generosity by my family of origin...it didn't really extend beyond the inner circle. And when that's true, that can put some major limits on the ways that we're able to be generous. 


And what has been so incredible about being part of The Church is that this is the place where I've found that expansiveness. I've seen how family doesn't have to be limited to these tiny, specific groups, but that through the church, we get to love each other in this really inclusive and beautiful way. 


I see this in some of the relationships that have popped up in the different rows of seats in this room. They're like little micro communities in our congregation. People who didn't really know each other before being here, but who by doing the simple thing of sitting in the same row, have become really important to each other. 


One of these stories is the connection that Heidi Beaver and Kylee, Phil, Dax, and Finn Larson have made. They kind of casually got to know each other as they sat near each other in church. But their relationship deepened when Finn, who is one now, was born. This is what Kylee told me: 


"Finn came and Heidi was so kind and sweet to both my boys. She would just hold Finn and he just loved her. She came to his birthday. My boys don't have any grandparents nearby, but I feel like God put her in our row to help them experience that feeling a little bit, and for me to feel the feeling of having someone who will just love your kids without reserve." 


Heidi told me how special the Larsons are to her, how she does indeed love getting her baby snuggles from Finn, but also just knowing them all. And she recalled that on the day she became a member here, in December of last year, she was holding tiny baby Finn when it was time for them all to come up and receive their certificates. So...she just brought Finn with her! (SLIDE) Kylee was actually leading with me that day, and Dax ended up following Heidi and Finn up here. Apparently when this happened, I made the comment that "church is not a solo sport"...and I have to tell you, I believed that then, and I believe it now! 


Because it's these kinds of connections that help make church just a little bit different than any other kind of gathering. We get to be here, with all these people who we might never meet otherwise, and we get to become an important part of each other's stories.  


And, as we become part of each other's stories, we also get to do good TOGETHER. We talked about that a bit last week, that this communal working together to do good is something that is sort of baked into our identity as a community. We know that we are going to show up and that there will be a chance for us to use whatever we might have, and that when we say yes to that invitation, it's going to matter.  


The church in Corinth was ready to do exactly that. What I think is interesting is that this part of the letter, even though it gives these super specific instructions for HOW to give...isn't an appeal for people TO give. Paul already assumes they will be willing to do that and it's part of their community practice. What Paul really wants them to know here is how they should prepare their gift for this other church and then he gives them lots of details about how this money will be used. They can give confidently that their gifts will be used to bless this other community and that they will be used well. 


I know some of you have had a chance to look at the Annual Report. If you haven't, I really hope you will! Our Communications Team did an incredible job putting it together and telling the story of what happened at St. Luke's in 2026.  


And there's a page in here, that sort of breaks the budget down, on page 34 (SLIDE). Now, I promise this won't get too business-y, but I think this is really important. Because we want you to know. We want you to know that when you give, HERE is the specific good that your gifts are doing. These are the ways that these intentions you make today will have real life impact. They'll impact our kids, our students, our small groups, our ability to provide care when people are going through a hard time, our resources to serve our community, the ability to keep our buildings maintained and in good shape. These gifts make it possible for us to be in this space together, week after week. The gifts you give help us welcome new people into this community, where they can find love and belonging. 


I think this year ahead for the Midtown Campus might be one of our most important yet. In just a couple of weeks, we're going to celebrate our 4th birthday as a campus! And with that fourth birthday comes a reminder for me—we're not really "new" anymore. We're about to have our 5th Christmas Eve together! We've got traditions now, and places we like to sit in the sanctuary. We've got things that get on our nerves and big dreams for how we could continue to grow. We've got questions and hopes and a lot of possibility stretching out in front of us.  


I think this next year ahead is going to be really focused on strengthening the relationships with the people who call this their church AND extending our connection to the community we're located in. We know that as a whole church, as St. Luke's, we're going to experience a huge transition with Pastor Rob's retirement and welcoming a new Senior Pastor. And I'm so excited to get to dream with this new pastor, to share the story of Midtown with them, to help them get to know you all and find ways to support the incredible ministry that's happening here. 


My prayer is that we at Midtown will find new ways to care for each other—whether that's through meeting the physical needs that we have or by creating spaces where we can show up exactly as we are and find our people. That we would love our neighbors in ways we've never done before. And that as we give—our time, our resources, our finances, our love—that we would experience God's grace through that giving.  


Every year, before our pledge moment, we watch our Year In Review Video. And this video gives us the SMALLEST glimpse of what God has done through St. Luke's this year. As you watch it, I hope that you'll experience gratitude for this church community. And I hope that you'll consider what it looks like to support our community in the year ahead. 


PLAY VIDEO 


In your bulletin, you have a pledge card. If you haven't filled that out, I want to invite you to do that now. And during this next song, you can come forward to turn in your cards. When you do that, you can take one of these St. Luke's mugs for your household just as a little thank you.  


Now, every single person here is invited to make an intention for the year ahead. AND, if you're new or this is your first time in this building and you're like, "oh no, I came on commitment Sunday," I don't want you to be nervous during this moment or think you have to sneak out if you're not making an intention. What I do want to invite you to do is pray for us. Pray that God would continue to work in us and through us and that we would use the gifts we have to do the most good we can. 


Let's pray together and then we will worship through song and through our intentions.  


PRAY