November 15, 2026
• Rev. Dr. Rob Fuquay
St. Luke’s UMC
November 15, 2026
Commitment Sunday
I Hate to Admit This But…True Confessions from a Pastor about Stewardship
“I Don’t Like Talking About Money in Church”
I Corinthians 16:1-4
James Harnish, founder of St. Luke’s United Methodist Church in Orlando, Fl once began a stewardship sermon sharing various approaches to talking about money that pastors use.
One is the Easy Payment Plan. “That’s where everyone does as little as possible. The preacher never mentions money, no one gets offended, and nothing ever happens.
Another is the Weep and Wail Approach where the preacher cries and wails about what a crisis the church is in. It is also called the “Running Mascara Approach” made popular by a TV evangelist at the time.
A third is The Hard Sell or Captain Hook approach. The preacher uses guilt and shame to its profitable potential.
And one more is the Pie-in-the-Sky Approach promising that you can buy your way into heaven like the pastor who visited the wealthy member who was about to die. The member asked, “If I give a million dollars to the church will guarantee that I get into heaven?” The pastor said, “You know I can’t answer that, but it’s worth a try.”
So no wonder that a lot of people don’t like hearing pastors talk about money in church. But did you know that a lot of pastors don’t like talking about money in church! And I would be one of them.
My discomfort talking about money in church, goes back to my upbringing. We didn’t talk about money. I had no idea what my parents made, how much our house cost. How much we had to live on. And especially, we didn’t talk about giving. Now, as I shared a few weeks ago, my dad taught me about responsibility with money. Spending wisely. Saving all I could. Holding onto it. But never about how to give.
Then I become a pastor and realize I have to talk to other people about giving. Fortunately I had been taught by a pastor about tithing and giving my 10% right away. But I found I wasn’t the only one who hadn’t been taught much about giving. These sermons weren’t so popular. People approached stewardship like something you grin and bear. So I was desperate to find a successful way to talk about money in church.
And then I read Paul’s approach. No guilt, no weeping, no hard sell. Just a plain, matter-of-fact discussion about money. “Now concerning the collection,” he wrote to the Corinthians.
The collection was for the poor in Jerusalem. There had been a terrible famine and people were starving and unable to provide for themselves. When the apostles in Jerusalem made the controversial decision to approve Paul’s ministry opening the church to non-Jewish people, Peter and James blessed Paul but asked that he receive offerings for the poor affected by the famine.
This was important to Paul. Not only did he care about helping the poor in Jerusalem, this offering was a validation of his ministry. If Gentile Christians cared enough to send gifts to Jewish Christians, it would show that they were all one church. So this was important to Paul. It wasn’t just taking up a collection. It was like Paul would be carrying their hearts of the Gentiles back to Jerusalem.
Oh, he could have started weeping and wailing when he talked about the offering. He could have put a guilt-trip on them. “The whole world-wide church depends on your gift!” He could have said, “If you don’t give, poor people in Jerusalem won’t have anything to eat!”
But he didn’t. He just talked plainly about money. At the beginning of each week, put aside whatever extra you earn for this collection and you can appoint some trustworthy people to deliver your gift. Just plain talk. Straight-forward. It doesn’t have to be awkward.
That’s what I learned later in life. Try to live on 80% on my income. Reduce my standard of living to 80%. Save 10%. Put it away for retirement and a savings account for emergencies. And then give away 10%.
A number of years ago I preached that here. I said, “If you aren’t accustomed to giving away 10% just try. Do it as an experiment, maybe for a month or quarter of the year. See what happens…
In the end we don’t have to cajole or guilt or hard-sell. Just talk honestly about how to give and what it can do for us. But in the end that is not enough. We also have to talk about how our money can be an expression of our faith.
There’s a lot of debate in worship classes as to where the offering should go in a service. Before or after the sermon. Many preachers feel it should go before the sermon. You won’t the sermon to uplift and inspire people, and if that happens, you don’t want to end the sermon and say, “Now let the ushers come forward and receive our offering.” What a downer!
But you know, Paul would have been in favor of putting the offering after the sermon. Think about where it appears in his letter. The scripture today is the start of chapter 16, the last chapter of 1 Corinthians. What comes right before it? Chapter 15, Paul’s magnum opus on the Resurrection. He responds to people’s questions about just what they should believe and Paul spends his lengthiest section of the entire letter preaching about resurrection and it gets to this climatic finish,
“Death has been swallowed up in victory.”
“Where, O death, is your victory?
Where, O death, is your sting?”
The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. But thanks be to God, who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.
Therefore, my beloved brothers and sisters, be steadfast, immovable, always excelling in the work of the Lord because you know that in the Lord your labor is not in vain.
Now, regarding the collection…
For Paul, that was no downer. I believe he put that in the order he intended, because the expression of our resurrection faith is what we give. What we do. This great faith in the resurrection of Christ is meant to break open the generosity of our hearts. And for Paul, this generosity is where our faith becomes real.
And you know what, that is where the faith has become real to me. In my ministry, faith has become real in what I have witnessed in the generosity of people in churches I have served.
My first appointment was two tiny churches in remote parts of the mountains in NC. I shared about our conference’s first building team to South Africa. Two men volunteered to go. So we held a fund-raising campaign to support them. One day I got a check in the mail for a widow who lived in a very simple home across from the church on the banks of the Pigeon River. It was for $200. I was in a quandary. I knew she did not have much and was afraid my enthusiasm and encouragement to give may have left her feeling she must do this. This was too much for her. In fact, I asked the all-knowing Google how much $200 in 1988 would be today…over $1200. So that’s no small amount.
I went to her home and handed back her check. I said, “We will reach our goal. We will get there. You don’t need to do this.” This was the only time she ever spoke sternly to me. She said, “You will take that check and put it toward this mission. Please do not deny me this joy!”
In my last church in NC we had an associate pastor who responded to an opportunity to become a partner church with a village in India. She and the woman who chaired the committee traveled there to see what we would do. They came back and organized a work team. We raised money and then at the last minute things fell through. The pastor was devastated. In her office she kept saying to the chairperson, “What are we going to do?” The other woman said, “Let’s pray.” As the praying the phone rang.
It was an organization in Charlotte that takes shoes to places around the world. We had worked with them. They asked if we’d deliver shoes to a village in Uganda. They just looked at each other in amazement.
The next thing you know they and a team from the church are in a remote area of Uganda handing out shoes to hundreds of children orphaned by AIDS. When they finished, the pastor of the village said, “Come with me and I’ll show you.” They weren’t sure but followed. He led them to an open field, “This is where you’ll build them!”
The pastor said, “Build what?”
He said, “The huts to house all the children.”
She said, “We just came to deliver shoes,” and he interrupted. He said, “No, we had a prayer service here and God told us He would send people to help us, and you showed up.”
The chair of the committee asked the pastor, “When did you have that prayer service?” He told her not only the date but the exact time, because he had written it down.
She checked her phone and showed it to the pastor. It was the exact time they got that call in her office.
So they come back and tell me all this. The next Sunday was Easter. I am preaching and have kind of an out of body experience. I tell this story, but stray from the script. I honestly wasn’t even aware of what I was saying. This was a wealthy lake community. I told them the cost of building a hut, $17,000. I ended my sermon, “So what are you going to do, buy another boat you don’t need or build a hut for kids in Africa?”
I got home for Easter lunch. No one was really talking. I sat down and said, “Did I really say that?” One of my daughters said, “Yeah, dad, you did.” And the phone rang. I thought, “here we go.”
A member of the church said, “Rob, I want to thank you for ruining our Easter lunch!” Then he laughed. He said, “Our family has been in discussion. Put us down for two huts!”
That pastor is till in partnership with that village. Here’s a picture of it today (2 pictures)
And then St. Luke’s. I don’t know where to start. The ways I see you give, resources, time, love, compassion. I feel like I am regularly stepping on and around sacred space because of all you do. I rub shoulders daily with saints. Just ordinary people giving of yourselves in ways that blow me away.
I could tell so many stories, but I’ll limit it to this one. We just recognized Kay Walla on All Saints’ Day. She passed away this year. She and husband, Gary, were very active in missions in Haiti. She wrote me one time to share this story. They were getting ready to lead a team to the Alpha and Omega Medical Clinic. Two sisters who were both nurses had planned to go, but at the last minute had to cancel. They said they were donating their $2,000 cost for the trip so that another nurse might be recruited.
Just a few minutes later Kay got an email from a woman, a registered nurse, saying she had recently been relieved from a high stress position. Now that she was unemployed she had time to go on a mission trip but just didn’t have the means. In worship here at St. Luke’s that morning she felt compelled to offer herself. She wrote, “I know this is a strange message, but God put it on her heart, so if she should hear of a benefactor interested in supporting a nurse…”
Kay ended the email this way, “With tears I was overwhelmed by just how much God was at work in our church today…”
See what I mean. People have shown me how faith becomes real through their generosity.
So No, I don’t like talking about money in church, but I will talk about giving all day long…